Current:Home > reviewsJudge rejects Trump's bid to dismiss classified documents case but agrees to strike an allegation in the charges -TruePath Finance
Judge rejects Trump's bid to dismiss classified documents case but agrees to strike an allegation in the charges
View
Date:2025-04-14 08:43:45
Washington — The federal judge overseeing special counsel Jack Smith's classified documents case against Donald Trump once again rejected requests by the former president's legal team to dismiss the charges against him, according to an order filed Monday evening.
Judge Aileen Cannon denied numerous claims by Trump's defense attorneys and his co-defendants arguing the 2023 indictment was technically flawed, but she criticized prosecutors' description of one incident as unnecessary to the charges and agreed to strike a single paragraph from the charging document because she said it "improperly contained uncharged offense allegations."
Smith charged Trump with 40 counts that include the unlawful retention of national defense information after investigators recovered hundreds of classified documents from his time in the White House at his Florida estate. The former president and his co-defendants — aide Walta Nauta and former Mar-a-Lago employee Carlos de Oliveira — are also accused of engaging in an alleged scheme to obstruct the federal probe.
All three have pleaded not guilty and denied wrongdoing.
Smith's office declined to comment on the recent ruling. Trump's representatives did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Trump, Nauta and de Oliveira made numerous arguments to the court in their bid to dismiss the charges before going to trial, including that several alleged crimes were listed under a single charge and that prosecutors failed to show Nauta and de Oliveria knew classified documents were contained in the boxes they are accused of moving. The defense also claimed the form in which the charges were written was technically insufficient.
Cannon rejected those claims because she said the language in the indictment was legally permissible. In some circumstances, she wrote the issues could be raised by the defense at trial.
Although a near-total win for Smith, the judge's ruling also criticized the style of the special counsel's indictment as containing "nonessential allegations more akin to a narrative about the government's theory of prosecution." Cannon wrote the "speaking indictment" — a term used to describe a descriptive charging document — contained allegations and language against Trump that were "legally unnecessary" to the underlying charges.
Despite the critique, she ruled nearly all of the 60-page indictment would stand, except for a single paragraph in which prosecutors described a moment in 2021 when Trump allegedly showed an individual who did not hold a security clearance a classified map of a foreign nation.
The judge wrote that the paragraph was unnecessary and would be stricken from the indictment, as Trump is not charged with showing anyone else classified records. She did, however, leave open the possibility that the alleged conduct could be included in any trial after proper litigation.
Her ruling was in line with comments she has made in past court hearings in which she specifically called the charging documents against Trump a "speaking indictment" and noted its length.
Cannon's order on Monday also mirrored others published in recent months in which she rejected Trump's legal arguments, but wrote critically of the special counsel and his prosecutors.
In April, she agreed with Smith that the names of potential witnesses should remain redacted in publicly filed documents, but scolded prosecutors for not making that particular argument sooner. Last month, Cannon criticized Smith's team for failing to confer with the defense and described them as "wholly lacking in substance and professional courtesy" when she rejected their request to limit Trump's speech about law enforcement on the case. Cannon did, however, allow the special counsel to refile his request and she is still considering it.
A trial date in the case has yet to be set as the judge said she is working through other pretrial matters. Cannon previously rejected other arguments brought by Trump that the charges should be dropped and has set public hearings on various motions throughout the summer months.
Smith also charged Trump in Washington, D.C., with four federal counts alleging he worked to subvert the results of the 2020 presidential election. The former president pleaded not guilty to those charges and the case is presently on hold as the Supreme Court considers his claims of presidential immunity from prosecution.
Robert LegareRobert Legare is a CBS News multiplatform reporter and producer covering the Justice Department, federal courts and investigations. He was previously an associate producer for the "CBS Evening News with Norah O'Donnell."
veryGood! (6762)
Related
- B.A. Parker is learning the banjo
- Ohio St., UGA, Michigan, FSU are CFP top 4. NCAA investigation of Wolverines not considered in rank
- 14 Curly Girl Must-Haves to Take Your Hair From Okay to Yay
- Georgia child welfare leader denies she asked judges to illegally detain children in juvenile jails
- Louvre will undergo expansion and restoration project, Macron says
- Two Massachusetts residents claim $1 million from different lottery games
- Ohio St., UGA, Michigan, FSU are CFP top 4. NCAA investigation of Wolverines not considered in rank
- Prosecutors in Manny Ellis trial enter its 5th week by questioning his closest allies
- Have Dry, Sensitive Skin? You Need To Add These Gentle Skincare Products to Your Routine
- Antisemitism policies at public city colleges in New York will be reviewed, the governor says
Ranking
- Which apps offer encrypted messaging? How to switch and what to know after feds’ warning
- Diamondbacks never found a fourth starter. They finally paid price in World Series rout.
- Halloween 2023: The special meaning behind teal, purple and blue pumpkins
- Addiction can lead to financial ruin. Ohio wants to teach finance pros to help stem the loss
- 'Squid Game' without subtitles? Duolingo, Netflix encourage fans to learn Korean
- Robert De Niro lashes out at former assistant who sued him, shouting: ‘Shame on you!’
- Senate Judiciary Committee to vote to authorize subpoenas to Harlan Crow, Leonard Leo as part of Supreme Court ethics probe
- House Republican seeks to change motion-to-vacate rule that brought down McCarthy
Recommendation
Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
Biden wants to protect your retirement savings from junk fees? Will it work?
The UK’s AI summit is taking place at Bletchley Park, the wartime home of codebreaking and computing
See Heidi Montag and Spencer Pratt’s Incredible Halloween Costume With Sons Gunner and Ryker
Don't let hackers fool you with a 'scam
Robert De Niro lashes out in court at ex-personal assistant who sued him: 'Shame on you!'
Massive windfarm project to be built off Virginia coast gains key federal approval
Trisha Paytas and Moses Hacmon Win Halloween With Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Costumes