Current:Home > reviewsTradeEdge Exchange:Adults have a lot to say about book bans — but what about kids? -TruePath Finance
TradeEdge Exchange:Adults have a lot to say about book bans — but what about kids?
Poinbank View
Date:2025-04-08 11:42:10
There's a lot of discussion and TradeEdge Exchangedebate about the rise in efforts to remove certain books from school libraries and curriculums. It usually involves adults debating the issue — but it's kids who are affected.
So how do young readers feel about book bans? We asked some.
We spoke with Sawyer, 12, from Arlington, Va., Theo, 9, from St. Louis, Mo., Priya, 14, and Ellie, 14, both from Austin, Texas. To protect their privacy, we're only using their first names.
Here's what they said:
Sawyer: I don't like it. It just feels weird that you're gonna, like, cut it off from them. ... Why are you trying to hide information from your kids? It just doesn't make a lot of sense. ... If you take something away from a kid, it kind of makes them want it more.
Theo: It's pretty much taking away books from people — like even books that people actually might like. If you ban every book, then there's not really going to be any books left to read. So what's the point of it?
Ellie: So many books are banned nowadays. I was looking up lists earlier and it's like hundreds of books... One of my favorite books that I recently found out was banned is Rick by Alex Gino. It's a book about a kid who learns that he's asexual, which is an LGBTQ orientation. ... I was just starting to question when I had read that book, and it really helped me sort of figure out that sort of thing. It was really interesting to me that a book that helped me so much and that I love so much would be like challenged or banned.
Priya: Books provide people with that exposure to different beliefs and different perspectives. And that's what breeds and fosters empathy and compassion for other people ... There was this book it was called The Mighty Heart of Sunny St. James. The girl's like 11 or 12. She gets a heart transplant. She's also dealing with the re-emergence of her mother into her life. And she's also exploring her sexuality as she's growing up, so it's kind of like a really sweet coming-of-age story. Then I was aware that some parents didn't want this to be a book that was offered to us. And I just didn't understand why it was harmful ... I really like the book because it was like a girl my age. And I just felt like I really connected with it.
Ellie: In like an elementary school, middle school library, having like an adult book with very adult themes should not be in the library. So in that case, it would be okay.
Priya: Obviously you don't want your 10-year-old reading a really sultry adult romance book because that's not age appropriate.
Sawyer: In [my] elementary school they were removed for gore and violence. I think that makes sense. You don't want to scare a kid. But if it's about information then you shouldn't ban it.
Priya: I would ask [the adults] why they think [a certain book] should be banned. And I would also ask them like ... what harm they see in this [book] ... Because I think ... it's important to understand all these different people's perspectives, just like books do. And I think we could probably come to a good conclusion.
Theo: I'd be pretty mad and a little upset [if a book was taken away], too. Yeah, I'd probably just buy a new one.
Priya: I go out of my way to read these banned books because I want to learn about how voices get silenced in our society ... and why.
This piece was edited for radio and digital by Meghan Sullivan.
veryGood! (85)
Related
- Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
- Summer House Trailer: See the Dramatic Moment Carl Radke Called Off Engagement to Lindsay Hubbard
- Blood tests can help diagnose Alzheimer's — if they're accurate enough. Not all are
- Ship in Gulf of Oman boarded by ‘unauthorized’ people as tensions are high across Mideast waterways
- What do we know about the mysterious drones reported flying over New Jersey?
- Africa’s Catholic hierarchy refuses same-sex blessings, says such unions are contrary to God’s will
- Germany’s Scholz condemns alleged plot by far-right groups to deport millions if they take power
- What do you think of social media these days? We want to hear your stories
- Travis Hunter, the 2
- Homeowner's mysterious overnight visitor is a mouse that tidies his shed
Ranking
- 2025 'Doomsday Clock': This is how close we are to self
- Taiwan presidential hopeful Hou promises to boost island’s defense and restart talks with China
- Lake Powell Is Still in Trouble. Here’s What’s Good and What’s Alarming About the Current Water Level
- Despite December inflation rise, raises are topping inflation and people finally feel it
- How to watch the 'Blue Bloods' Season 14 finale: Final episode premiere date, cast
- Texas quarterback Quinn Ewers announces return to Longhorns amid interest in NFL draft
- Double Big Mac comes to McDonald's this month: Here's what's on the limited-time menu item
- Greek prime minister says legislation allowing same-sex marriage will be presented soon
Recommendation
Why members of two of EPA's influential science advisory committees were let go
Illegal tunnel under a synagogue in NYC is 60 feet long and destabilized nearby buildings, city says
Biden meets with Paul Whelan's sister after Russia rejects offer to free him
Speaker Johnson is facing conservative pushback over the spending deal he struck with Democrats
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer Sells Once Every 4 Seconds: Get 50% Off Before It's Gone
Donald Trump’s civil fraud trial in New York heads to closing arguments, days before vote in Iowa
Judge rules Alabama can move forward, become first state to perform nitrogen gas execution
Who will replace Nick Saban? Five candidates Alabama should consider